The Battle of Franklin, Tennessee November 30, 1864; A statement of the erroneous claims made by General Schofield, and an exposition of the blunder which opened the battle   By: John K. Shellenberger (1843?-)

John K. Shellenberger's book, The Battle of Franklin, Tennessee November 30, 1864; A statement of the erroneous claims made by General Schofield, and an exposition of the blunder which opened the battle, offers a meticulous and comprehensive analysis of an important historical event. Shellenberger's work delves into the intricacies of the battle fought during the American Civil War, shining a light on the often-overlooked mistakes and misconceptions that shaped its outcome.

The author begins by laying out the historical context, providing readers with the necessary background information to fully understand the significance of the Battle of Franklin. Shellenberger's attention to detail is evident through his meticulous research, which is showcased in his thorough examination of primary sources and expert interviews.

One of the book's main strengths lies in Shellenberger's ability to challenge popular historical narratives. He identifies and addresses the erroneous claims made by General Schofield, a prominent figure during the battle, carefully dissecting the inaccuracies and shedding light on previously unseen perspectives. By doing so, Shellenberger challenges readers to reconsider widely accepted accounts of this historical event.

Additionally, the author skillfully exposes the blunder that marked the beginning of the battle. Through a combination of eyewitness accounts and well-documented evidence, Shellenberger critically analyzes the tactical errors and strategic oversights that occurred, ultimately reshaping the readers' understanding of this crucial moment in history.

Shellenberger's prose is clear, concise, and accessible to both general readers and Civil War enthusiasts. His well-structured narrative ensures that readers can easily follow the flow of events, while his inclusion of maps and illustrations further enhances the comprehension of the battle's complexities.

While the book is undoubtedly impressive in its attention to detail and thorough research, it occasionally suffers from an overly academic tone. At times, readers may find themselves bogged down by the extensive citation of primary sources and a surplus of minute details. However, dedicated history buffs will appreciate this level of depth and the book's scholarly approach.

In conclusion, The Battle of Franklin, Tennessee November 30, 1864; A statement of the erroneous claims made by General Schofield, and an exposition of the blunder which opened the battle by John K. Shellenberger is an invaluable contribution to the historiography of the American Civil War. Shellenberger's meticulous research and critical analysis provide readers with a fresh perspective, challenging preconceived notions and illuminating previously overlooked aspects of the battle. Despite its occasional scholarly tone, this book is an essential read for anyone interested in delving deeper into the complexities of this historical event.

First Page:

I have no personal grudge against General Schofield, whose obstinate reliance on his ability to foresee what General Hood would do, was the prime cause of the blunder. My feeling towards him is the same that any honest student will experience when he becomes convinced that an undeserved promotion was secured by dishonest methods... Continue reading book >>