The Best Short Stories of 1917 and the Yearbook of the American Short Story   By: Edward Joseph Harrington O'Brien (1890-1941)

The Best Short Stories of 1917 and the Yearbook of the American Short Story, edited by Edward Joseph Harrington O'Brien, offers readers a captivating glimpse into the literary landscape of the early 20th century. This anthology showcases a diverse range of narratives from renowned authors and emerging voices, painting an evocative portrait of America during this pivotal time in history.

One of the anthology's notable strengths lies in O'Brien's meticulous curation of stories that reflect the issues, concerns, and aspirations of the era. From tales exploring the aftermaths of World War I to narratives grappling with social, cultural, and political changes, the collection leaves no stone unturned. The diversity of themes ensures that readers will find stories that speak to them on both personal and universal levels.

Another aspect that sets this anthology apart is O'Brien's insightful commentary surrounding each story. His well-researched introductions provide valuable historical context, shedding light on the circumstances under which these stories were written. This enriches the reading experience, allowing us to appreciate the stories beyond their literary merits and examine them as historical artifacts.

The stories themselves are a true testament to the wealth of talent found in American literature during this time. From well-known authors such as Edith Wharton and Sherwood Anderson to lesser-known but equally deserving writers, each story is a gem in its own right. The authors skillfully weave vivid descriptions, nuanced characterizations, and thought-provoking dialogue to create narratives that stay with the reader long after the final page.

While the anthology showcases numerous powerful stories, a few standout pieces are worthy of special mention. Mary Heaton Vorse's "Woman on the Scaffold" exposes the vulnerability of women in an age of rapid societal transformations. F. Scott Fitzgerald's "The Baby Party" exhibits his keen ability to capture the conflicted emotions of young adults navigating social expectations and personal desires. These stories, and others, embody the essence of the era, capturing the hopes, dreams, and struggles of the American people with remarkable poignancy.

However, no anthology is without its flaws. Some readers may find the absence of certain authors or stories disappointing, as personal preferences inevitably come into play. Additionally, while O'Brien's commentary bolsters the collection, at times it can feel overly lengthy and encroaches on the reader's own interpretation and exploration of the stories.

In conclusion, The Best Short Stories of 1917 and the Yearbook of the American Short Story serves as a valuable window into the past, allowing readers to immerse themselves in the creative brilliance of early 20th-century American literature. O'Brien's careful selection and insightful commentary make this anthology a must-read for both aficionados of the era and those seeking a deeper understanding of America's cultural, social, and literary history.

First Page:

To The Pictorial Review Company and Miss Edwina Stanton Babcock for permission to reprint "The Excursion," first published in The Pictorial Review ; to The Century Company and Mr... Continue reading book >>