The Confutatio Pontificia   By: Johann Michael Reu (1869-1943)

The Confutatio Pontificia by Johann Michael Reu is a thought-provoking and meticulously researched book that explores the historical roots and present-day implications of the Protestant Reformation. Reu masterfully dissects the arguments put forth by Roman Catholic theologians in response to Martin Luther's teachings, providing a compelling counter-argument in favor of Protestantism.

One of the book's strengths lies in Reu's ability to clearly present complex theological concepts in a manner accessible to both scholars and lay readers alike. Through a blend of historical analysis, scriptural exegesis, and logical reasoning, Reu effectively critiques the doctrines defended by Roman Catholic authorities during the Counter-Reformation.

Throughout the book, Reu juxtaposes the teachings of the Roman Catholic Church against those of early Christian theologians and the Reformers themselves. By doing so, he highlights the theological inconsistencies and deviations from biblical truth found within Catholic dogma. This comparative approach not only enhances our understanding of Protestant doctrines but also deepens our appreciation for the intellectual and spiritual struggle of the Reformers.

Reu's work is also notable for its comprehensive scope. With keen attention to detail, he examines various areas of disagreement between Protestantism and Catholicism, such as the doctrine of justification, the nature of the church, the role of tradition, and the authority of the pope. Each topic is meticulously analyzed, presenting a thorough and well-reasoned defense of the Protestant position.

Moreover, Reu's writing style is clear, concise, and engaging, making the book a pleasure to read. Although dealing with weighty theological matters, the author avoids unnecessary jargon and presents his arguments in a logical and accessible manner. This clarity of expression greatly aids the reader in following the author's reasoning and strengthens the book's overall impact.

While The Confutatio Pontificia primarily defends the Protestant perspective, Reu's approach remains respectful and fair towards his Catholic counterparts. The book neither resorts to polemics nor denigrates opposing viewpoints; rather, it seeks to engage in a respectful and honest dialogue. This approach enables readers regardless of their religious affiliation to gain a deeper understanding of the reasons behind the formation of Protestant Christianity.

In conclusion, The Confutatio Pontificia by Johann Michael Reu is an insightful and scholarly examination of the theological issues surrounding the Protestant Reformation. From its meticulous research to its logical arguments, the book showcases Reu's mastery of the subject matter. It is undoubtedly a valuable resource for anyone interested in the history of Christianity, theological debate, or ecumenical dialogue.

First Page:

As His Worshipful Imperial Majesty received several days since a Confession of Faith presented by the Elector the duke of Saxony and several princes and two cities, to which their names were affixed, with his characteristic zeal for the glory of God, the salvation of souls, Christian harmony and the public peace, he not only himself read the Confession, but also, in order that in a matter of such moment he might proceed the more thoroughly and seasonably, he referred the aforesaid Confession to several learned, mature, approved and honorable men of different nations for their inspection and examination, and earnestly directed and enjoined them to praise and approve what in the Confession was said aright and in accord with Catholic doctrine, but, on the other hand, to note that wherein it differed from the Catholic Church, and, together with their reply, to present and explain their judgment on each topic... Continue reading book >>