The Indian Question   By: Francis Amasa Walker (1840-1897)

In Francis Amasa Walker's thought-provoking work, he delves deep into the complex issue of the Indian Question in the United States. With thorough research and careful analysis, the author presents a comprehensive examination of the struggles faced by Native Americans during the 19th century.

Walker's writing is clear, concise, and backed by a wealth of historical evidence. His narrative takes readers on a journey through the intricate history of Native American tribes, their encounters with European colonizers, and the subsequent conflicts that arose. Through his detailed exploration, he sheds light on the detrimental effects of policies enacted by the U.S. government, which often resulted in the displacement and marginalization of Indigenous peoples.

One of the book's notable strengths is the author's ability to depict the diverse perspectives of both the Native American tribes and the government officials who sought to assimilate or remove them. Walker presents a balanced account of the conflicts and negotiations, offering readers a more nuanced understanding of the Indian Question as a whole.

Additionally, the author's inclusion of primary sources, such as speeches and treaties, enriches the narrative by providing firsthand accounts of the events and policies discussed. These sources further demonstrate the systemic injustices faced by Native Americans and emphasize the urgency of addressing the widespread issues highlighted in the book.

However, some readers may find Walker's language and style to be slightly dense, particularly when discussing economic and statistical analyses. Although this could deter some from fully engaging with the material, these sections enhance the book's scholarly credibility and offer a deeper understanding of the economic complexities influencing governmental decisions concerning Native Americans.

Overall, Francis Amasa Walker's The Indian Question is a crucial contribution to the historiography of Native American struggles in the United States. With its meticulous research, fair analysis, and incorporation of primary sources, this book serves as an indispensable resource for those seeking a comprehensive understanding of the complex dynamics between Indigenous peoples and the U.S. government. Walker's work prompts readers to reflect on the lingering effects of historical injustices and the importance of creating a more equitable future for all.

First Page:

Brave words these would have seemed to good William Penn, treating with the Lenni Lenape, under the elm at Kensington; or even to doughty Miles Standish, ready as that worthy ever was to march against the heathen who troubled his Israel. Heathen they were in the eyes of the good people of Plymouth Colony, but nations of heathen, without question, as truly as were the Amalekites, the Jebusites, or the Hittites to the infant colony at Shiloh... Continue reading book >>