John Brown: A Retrospect Read before The Worcester Society of Antiquity, Dec. 2, 1884.   By: Alfred S. (Alfred Seelye) Roe (1844-1917)

In John Brown: A Retrospect Read before The Worcester Society of Antiquity, Dec. 2, 1884, author Alfred S. Roe provides a comprehensive and insightful analysis of the life and legacy of John Brown. With his meticulous research and engaging prose, Roe successfully delves into the historical context and significance of this controversial figure.

One of the most commendable aspects of this book is Roe's ability to present a balanced and unbiased view of Brown. Rather than romanticizing or vilifying him, Roe presents a nuanced portrayal that allows readers to form their own conclusions about the man and his actions. This objective approach is a refreshing departure from other works on Brown, which tend to polarize opinions.

Roe's research is undoubtedly extensive, as evidenced by the numerous sources he references throughout the book. From letters and diaries to historical records and newspapers, he leaves no stone unturned in his quest to shed light on the many facets of Brown's life. By relying on primary sources, Roe gives readers a genuine and authentic account of the events and individuals surrounding Brown.

Furthermore, Roe's narrative style is both accessible and engaging, making this book a pleasurable read for both casual readers and history enthusiasts. Despite the extensive research, Roe avoids overwhelming readers with excessive details, instead focusing on presenting a coherent and captivating narrative. The result is a well-paced and informative account of Brown's life that keeps readers invested throughout.

One aspect that could have been improved upon is the book's organization. While the overall structure of the book follows a chronological order, some sections can feel disjointed and lack a clear transition. This occasional lack of cohesion may confuse readers and disrupt the flow of the narrative. However, the clarity and depth of Roe's analysis ultimately compensate for this minor flaw.

In conclusion, John Brown: A Retrospect is an exceptional work that offers a comprehensive examination of one of history's most controversial figures. Alfred S. Roe's meticulous research, balanced perspective, and engaging writing style make this book a valuable addition to any history lover's collection. Anyone interested in understanding the complexities of John Brown's life and impact on American history will find this book an enlightening and thought-provoking read.

First Page:

I am advised that one of "U.S. Hounds is on my track"; & I have kept myself hid for a few days to let my track get cold. I have no idea of being taken; & intend ( if "God will";) to go back with Irons in rather than upon my hands. Now my Dear Sir let me ask you to have Mr. Allen & Co. send me by Express; one or two sample Navy Sized Revolvers; as soon as may be ; together with his best cash terms (he warranting them) by the hundred with good moulds, flasks; &c. I wish the sample Pistols sent to John (not Capt) Brown Care of Massasoit House Springfield, Mass. I now enclose Twenty Dollars towards repairs done for me; & Revolvers; the balance I will send , as soon as I get the Bill. I have written to have Dr. Howe send you by Express a Rifle and Two Pistols; which with the guns you gave me; & fixings; together with the Rifle given me by Mr. Allen & Co. I wish them to pack in a suitable strong Box; perfectly safe directing to J.B. care of Orson M. Oviatt Esq. Cleveland Ohio; as freight ; to keep dry. For Box, trouble; & packing; I will pay when I get bill... Continue reading book >>