The Problem of 'Edwin Drood' A Study in the Methods of Dickens   By: W. Robertson Nicoll

In "The Problem of 'Edwin Drood': A Study in the Methods of Dickens," W. Robertson Nicoll delves into the unique literary conundrum left unsolved by the untimely death of Charles Dickens. With meticulous scholarly analysis, Nicoll dissects the mysteries surrounding Dickens' final unfinished novel, "The Mystery of Edwin Drood."

From the onset, Nicoll proves himself a master of Dickensian knowledge, seamlessly blending historical context, literary technique, and intricate character analyses to create a comprehensive study of this enigmatic work. His deep understanding of Dickens' narrative style provides readers with a profound appreciation for the author's distinctive storytelling methods.

Nicoll expertly navigates through the complex web of unanswered questions surrounding "The Mystery of Edwin Drood," presenting multiple theories and engaging with a wide range of scholarly perspectives. Whether examining the influence of Dickens' personal life on the novel or dissecting the intricate plot threads left dangling, the author's persuasive arguments leave readers captivated and hungry for more insights.

One of the most remarkable aspects of Nicoll's analysis is his ability to shape the ongoing debate surrounding the book's unresolved ending. By skillfully highlighting the significance of different clues and narrative choices, he not only provides his own interpretations but also encourages readers to form their own conclusions. This interactive approach elevates the study beyond a simple exegesis, transforming it into a discourse that invites readers to engage actively with the text.

Nicoll's research is both comprehensive and meticulous, leaving no stone unturned as he examines the broader literary landscape within which Dickens wrote. Through extensive analysis of previous works, periodicals, and even correspondence, he situates "The Mystery of Edwin Drood" within the context of Dickens' broader body of work, revealing unexpected connections and shedding light on the development of the novel.

While the subject matter can be dense at times, Nicoll's clear and engaging writing style ensures accessibility for readers of various backgrounds. He strikes a delicate balance between scholarly rigor and readability, ensuring that his book can be appreciated both by seasoned Dickens enthusiasts and those encountering the author's work for the first time.

If there is any flaw in "The Problem of 'Edwin Drood'," it lies in its slight bias toward asserting the impossibility of definitively solving the mystery. While Nicoll offers compelling arguments and plausible explanations for various plot points, he embraces the ambiguous nature of Dickens' unfinished work. Yet, this might be seen as a strength rather than a weakness, as it encourages readers to appreciate the open-ended nature of literature and the enduring allure of Dickens' final masterpiece.

In conclusion, W. Robertson Nicoll's "The Problem of 'Edwin Drood': A Study in the Methods of Dickens" is an exceptional exploration of one of literature's greatest mysteries. Through meticulous research and insightful analysis, Nicoll offers a comprehensive examination of "The Mystery of Edwin Drood," leaving readers with a newfound appreciation for Dickens' literary genius. Whether an avid Dickens fan or a lover of literary puzzles, this book is sure to captivate and challenge readers in equal measure.

First Page:

PAGE PREFACE ix INTRODUCTION xvii PART I.—THE MATERIALS FOR A SOLUTION CHAPTER I THE TEXT OF ‘EDWIN DROOD’ 3 CHAPTER II EXTERNAL TESTIMONIES 20 NOTES FOR THE NOVEL 56 CHAPTER III THE ILLUSTRATIONS ON THE WRAPPER 69 CHAPTER IV THE METHODS OF DICKENS 82 PART II... Continue reading book >>