Remarks on a Pamphlet Lately published by the Rev. Mr. Maskelyne, Under the Authority of the Board of Longitude   By: John Harrison

Remarks on a Pamphlet Lately published by the Rev. Mr. Maskelyne, Under the Authority of the Board of Longitude is an impactful and thought-provoking piece of work by John Harrison. In this comprehensive critique, Harrison delves into the claims and arguments put forward by Rev. Mr. Maskelyne regarding the issue of determining longitude at sea.

The book begins with a clear and concise summary of the pamphlet, presenting the core points made by Maskelyne. Harrison proceeds to dissect these assertions with meticulous attention to detail, revealing flaws in both the scientific and practical aspects of Maskelyne's arguments. His logical and evidence-based rebuttals bolstered by his own expertise in horology provide a highly convincing counter-argument.

Harrison's writing style is accessible and engaging, making it easy for readers to follow his line of reasoning. He presents complex ideas and scientific concepts with clarity, ensuring that even those without a deep understanding of the subject matter can comprehend his points. The author's passion for his work shines through, lending an air of excitement to his examination of the intricacies surrounding the measurement of longitude.

One notable aspect of this book is how Harrison combines scientific analysis with historical context. He skillfully weaves together the development of longitude measurement techniques with the events that unfolded within the Board of Longitude, providing readers with a comprehensive understanding of the significance of Maskelyne's pamphlet within its historical context.

Furthermore, Harrison takes care to address competing theories and proposals, providing a well-rounded discussion that encourages readers to critically evaluate multiple perspectives. His ability to present opposing sides in a fair and unbiased manner grants the reader the opportunity to form their own conclusions based on the evidence presented.

However, one slight drawback is the occasional repetitiveness found in some sections. While Harrison's thoroughness is commendable, there are instances where he reiterates certain points more than necessary. This redundancy might hinder the book's overall flow and lead to a slight loss of reader engagement.

Despite this minor flaw, the book remains an incredibly valuable resource for those interested in the field of horology, the history of navigation, or the scientific advancements that have shaped our understanding of the world. Harrison's meticulous research, well-structured arguments, and undeniable expertise make Remarks on a Pamphlet Lately published by the Rev. Mr. Maskelyne, Under the Authority of the Board of Longitude an essential read for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of the crucial role accurate longitude measurement played in the exploration of the seas.

First Page:

A Publication having lately been made by the Rev. Mr. Maskelyne Astronomer Royal, under the Authority of the Board of Longitude, manifestly tending, by the Suppression of some Facts and the Misrepresentation of others, to impress the World with an unjust Opinion of my Invention, and falsely asserting that my Watch did not at certain Periods therein mentioned keep Time with sufficient Exactness to determine the Longitude within the Limits prescribed by the Act of the 12th of Queen Anne ; I think it incumbent upon me to submit some Observations thereon to the impartial Publick; and the rather, because the said Pamphlet is rendered so confused by unnecessary Repetitions, and voluminous Tables, that a Man must be pretty conversant in these Matters, to trace and combine the Facts, so as to check the Conclusions, which would consequently be taken upon Trust by the generality of Readers, unless publickly contradicted... Continue reading book >>