Books Should Be Free
Loyal Books
Free Public Domain Audiobooks & eBook Downloads
Search by: Title, Author or Keyword

Review of the Work of Mr John Stuart Mill Entitled, 'Examination of Sir William Hamilton's Philosophy.'   By: (1794-1871)

Book cover

In his ambitious philosophical work, "Examination of Sir William Hamilton's Philosophy," John Stuart Mill delves into a comprehensive critique of the renowned Scottish philosopher's ideas. Published in 1865, this profound treatise encapsulates Mill's analytical prowess and unabated dedication to scrutinizing the foundations of Hamilton’s metaphysical doctrines. In providing an insightful analysis, Mill presents a compelling argument against Hamilton’s theories, challenging long-held beliefs and proposing alternative perspectives on fundamental philosophical concepts.

As an esteemed and influential figure in the field of philosophy himself, Mill skillfully dissects Hamilton’s theories, uncovering what he perceives as inherent contradictions and weaknesses. Mill's approach is meticulous and rigorous, leaving no stone unturned. He scrutinizes Hamilton’s views on causality, perception, and the nature of reality with meticulous attention to detail, through astute logical reasoning and compelling examples.

One of the most compelling aspects of Mill's work is his ability to articulate his ideas with utmost clarity and coherence, making complex philosophical concepts accessible to a wide range of readers. He employs precise and concise language, eliminating any ambiguity that might arise when discussing intricate philosophical matters. Moreover, Mill’s writing style is engaging and compelling, commanding the reader's attention while unraveling intricate arguments.

Throughout the book, Mill presents a robust defense of several philosophical doctrines, such as the laws of thought and the theory of causation. His criticisms of Hamilton's views are well-founded and do not solely rely on refutation; instead, Mill offers alternative explanations, shedding light on fresh perspectives and prompting readers to reexamine their own preconceived notions.

One element that particularly stands out in Mill's examination is his firm commitment to rationalism and empiricism. He extensively explores Hamilton's overreliance on authority and argues for the necessity of challenging traditional dogmas. This unwavering commitment to reason is woven throughout Mill's work, emphasizing the enduring relevance and importance of critical thinking in philosophical discourse.

In addition to his examination of Hamilton's theories, Mill also includes insightful reflections on the nature and purpose of philosophy itself. He addresses the limitations of philosophical systems, emphasizing the necessity of ongoing inquiry and revision. This introspective aspect of Mill’s work adds further depth to his critique, inviting the reader to engage in the intellectual journey alongside him.

While Mill's work is undoubtedly thought-provoking, it is not without its flaws. At times, his critique may appear overly harsh or dismissive of opposing views, potentially alienating those who hold different philosophical beliefs. Additionally, some readers may find Mill's writing style excessively dense and intricate, requiring sustained effort to fully comprehend.

Nevertheless, "Examination of Sir William Hamilton's Philosophy" stands as a seminal piece of philosophical scholarship. Mill's meticulous analysis and comprehensive examination not only dismantle Hamilton's theories but also contribute to the ongoing evolution of philosophical thought. This work serves as a testament to Mill's intellectual prowess and enduring impact on the field of philosophy itself.

George Grote's review of Mill's work provides a valuable perspective on its significance. Grote emphasizes the originality and rigor of Mill's critique, praising his meticulousness and intellectual rigor. Grote's review serves as a fitting endorsement of Mill's formidable analytical prowess and contributes to the recognition of "Examination of Sir William Hamilton's Philosophy" as a monumental work in the annals of philosophical discourse.

First Page:

REVIEW OF THE WORK OF MR JOHN STUART MILL

ENTITLED, 'EXAMINATION OF SIR WILLIAM HAMILTONS PHILOSOPHY'

BY GEORGE GROTE

AUTHOR OF

'THE HISTORY OF ANCIENT GREECE,'

'PLATO AND THE OTHER COMPANIONS OF SOCRATES,' ETC.

1868

Reprinted from the 'Westminster Review,' January 1, 1866.

JOHN CHILDS AND SON, PRINTERS

An Examination of Sir William Hamilton's Philosophy, and of the Principal Philosophical Questions discussed in his Writings . By JOHN STUART MILL. London: Longmans. 1865.

The work bearing the above title is an octavo volume, consisting of twenty eight chapters, and five hundred and sixty pages. This is no great amount of print; but the amount of matter contained in it is prodigious, and the quality of that matter such as to require a full stretch of attention. Mr Mill gives his readers no superfluous sentences, scarcely even a superfluous word, above what is necessary to express his meaning briefly and clearly. Of such a book no complete abstract can be given in the space to which we are confined.

To students of philosophy doubtless but a minority among the general circle of English readers this work comes recommended by the strongest claims both of interest and instruction. It presents in direct antithesis two most conspicuous representatives of the modern speculative mind of England Sir W... Continue reading book >>




eBook Downloads
ePUB eBook
• iBooks for iPhone and iPad
• Nook
• Sony Reader
Kindle eBook
• Mobi file format for Kindle
Read eBook
• Load eBook in browser
Text File eBook
• Computers
• Windows
• Mac

Review this book



Popular Genres
More Genres
Languages
Paid Books