Selections from Previous Works and Remarks on Romanes' Mental Evolution in Animals   By: Samuel Butler (1835-1902)

In "Selections from Previous Works and Remarks on Romanes' Mental Evolution in Animals," Samuel Butler provides readers with a thought-provoking collection of writings that delve into various topics related to psychology, science, and evolution. While the book may not be widely known, it offers a unique perspective and insights that make it worth exploring for those interested in these areas.

Butler, recognized for his contrarian stance and critical thinking, presents a compilation of various essays and excerpts from his previous works. One of the standout features of this book is its ability to engage readers in an intellectual dialogue, challenging established ideas and inviting them to question the prevailing scientific beliefs of the time.

At the heart of this collection, Butler addresses George Romanes' theory of mental evolution in animals and puts forth his own counterarguments. He scrutinizes Romanes' claims and systematically deconstructs them, presenting a thorough critique that showcases Butler's own grasp of the subject matter. This critical analysis provides readers with a fresh perspective, encouraging them to reflect on the limitations of Romanes' theories and consider alternative explanations.

Although the book predominantly focuses on Romanes' work, it also encompasses other engaging chapters drawn from Butler's previous publications. These selections touch on diverse subjects such as consciousness, artificial selection, and the relationship between humans and animals. By revisiting these writings, readers gain insight into Butler's evolving views over the years, witnessing the development of his ideas and sharpening of his arguments.

Butler's writing style is both accessible and thought-provoking, blending scientific analysis with philosophical reflections. His ability to convey complex concepts in a coherent manner allows readers from various backgrounds to grasp the essence of his arguments. The depth of his knowledge and his ability to argue persuasively make for a compelling read.

While Selections from Previous Works and Remarks on Romanes' Mental Evolution in Animals showcases the brilliance of Samuel Butler's ideas, it may not appeal to those seeking a casual or light read. The book demands concentration and an interest in the subject matter to fully appreciate its value. However, for readers who are eager to explore the intricacies of scientific theories and engage in challenging intellectual debates, this collection presents a valuable opportunity.

In conclusion, Selections from Previous Works and Remarks on Romanes' Mental Evolution in Animals is a captivating compilation of Samuel Butler's thought-provoking writings. It delves into crucial scientific and philosophical matters while providing readers with an intellectual journey that challenges established theories. Though it may not be widely recognized, this book offers a wealth of knowledge and will undoubtedly leave a lasting impression on those who remain open to its unconventional ideas.

First Page:

This Mr. Romanes has not thought it incumbent upon him to give. I am told I ought not to have expected him to give it, inasmuch as it is no longer usual for men of any but the lowest scientific standing to correct their misstatements when they are brought to book. Science is made for Fellows of the Royal Society, and for no one else, not Fellows of the Royal Society for science; and if the having achieved a certain position should still involve being obliged to be as scrupulous and accurate as other people, what is the good of the position? This view of the matter is practical, but I regret that Mr... Continue reading book >>