Sex in Education or, A Fair Chance for Girls   By: Edward H. (Edward Hammond) Clarke (1820-1877)

In "Sex in Education or, A Fair Chance for Girls", Edward H. Clarke raises important questions about the impact of education on the physical and mental well-being of young girls. Published in 1873, this book offers a unique look into the prevailing mindset surrounding women's rights and the limitations imposed on them in both academia and society during that era.

Clarke begins by arguing that the current educational system puts undue strain on young girls, often leading to detrimental effects on their health. He contends that girls possess a delicate constitution, emphasizing their need for protection from excessive mental and physical exertion. Clarke's main point suggests that the education system, as practiced at the time, neglected these differences in favor of a one-size-fits-all approach.

Using a combination of historical observations, anecdotal evidence, and medical case studies, the author asserts that educational pressures, especially in the form of intense studying, can lead to adverse effects such as nervous disorders and physical ailments in young girls. He highlights instances where girls, who were once vibrant and healthy, became frail and weak due to excessive educational demands.

Clarke's views on potential consequences arising from girls' education were aligned with the social norms of the time. While his intentions may have been well-meaning, it is important to critically analyze his arguments, considering the significant progress made since the book's publication. Modern society recognizes the inherent value and potential of all individuals, irrespective of their gender or perceived physical limitations.

When reviewing this book, it is crucial to approach it within the historical context of its era. While some of the arguments put forth may no longer hold validity, it offers an opportunity to understand the prevailing attitudes towards women's rights and health during the period. The book's contribution lies in shedding light on the challenges faced by women seeking education and how societal and cultural beliefs intersected with the educational system to hinder their progress.

Overall, "Sex in Education or, A Fair Chance for Girls" serves as a valuable resource to comprehend the attitudes and obstacles faced by women in the late 19th century. Readers should approach the book with a critical perspective, adapted to the progress achieved in modern society, to fully appreciate its historical significance.

First Page:

Member of the Massachusetts Medical Society; Fellow of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences; Late Professor of Materia Medica in Harvard College, Etc... Continue reading book >>