Then Marched the Brave   By: Harriet T. (Harriet Theresa) Comstock (1860-)

Then Marched the Brave by Harriet T. Comstock is a compelling historical fiction novel that brings to life the lesser-known stories of women in the American Civil War. Set in the 1860s, the book follows the journey of two courageous women, Emma Edmonds and Alice, who defy societal expectations to join the war effort.

The author's meticulous research is evident throughout the narrative, as she seamlessly intertwines historical facts with fictional characters. The attention to detail in describing the battlefield scenes and the emotions of the characters is commendable, making the reader feel as if they are witnessing the events firsthand.

Emma Edmonds, who assumes the identity of a man named Frank Thompson, embarks on a daring adventure as a Union soldier. Comstock brilliantly portrays the struggles Emma faces as she adapts to military life, feigns her gender identity, and confronts the horrors of war. Emma's determination, resilience, and sacrifices are truly inspiring, shedding light on the untold stories of women who disguised themselves as men to serve their country.

Alice, on the other hand, remains loyal to her Confederate roots and becomes a spy. Her character showcases the complexities of war, highlighting the internal conflicts and difficult choices faced by those on opposing sides. Alice's unwavering dedication to her cause and her resourcefulness in carrying out her missions add depth and intrigue to the story.

One of the strengths of Then Marched the Brave is the portrayal of female camaraderie and the bonds formed in the face of adversity. The author explores the deep friendships that develop between Emma and her fellow soldiers, as well as the support network that Alice finds within her spy network. These relationships serve as a reminder of the strength that can be found in unity and sisterhood.

While the pacing of the novel is generally well-maintained, there are moments when the narrative feels slightly sluggish. Some chapters delve too deep into historical context, which may slow down the overall momentum. However, this flaw is easily overlooked due to the captivating characters and the immersive historical setting that the author creates.

Overall, Then Marched the Brave is a captivating and revealing portrayal of the women who fought and served in the American Civil War. Harriet T. Comstock's vivid storytelling and well-developed characters make this book a must-read for history enthusiasts and anyone who appreciates tales of courage and resilience.

First Page:

It was in the time when the king's men had things pretty much their own way, and mystery and plot held full sway, that there lived, in a little house near McGown Pass on the upper end of Manhattan Island, a widow and her lame son. She was a tall, gaunt woman of Scotch ancestry, but loyal to the land that had given her a second home... Continue reading book >>