An Enquiry into the Truth of the Tradition, Concerning the Discovery of America, by Prince Madog ab Owen Gwynedd, about the Year, 1170   By: John Williams (1727-1798)

In "An Enquiry into the Truth of the Tradition, Concerning the Discovery of America, by Prince Madog ab Owen Gwynedd, about the Year 1170," John Williams skillfully delves into the controversial and lesser-known narrative surrounding the discovery of America. Williams's meticulous research and insightful analysis provide readers with a compelling account that challenges conventional historical understanding.

Throughout the book, Williams methodically examines the tradition of Prince Madog ab Owen Gwynedd's alleged voyage across the Atlantic and subsequent colonization of parts of America, expanding on the debates and skepticism surrounding this often-dismissed theory. Based on a range of historical sources, Williams presents a comprehensive assessment of the evidence, tracing the origins of the Madoc myth to the 16th century and shedding light on its enduring cultural prominence.

One of the strengths of Williams's work lies in his ability to contextualize the Prince Madog narrative within broader historical and geographical frameworks. He meticulously dissects various accounts, weighing their merits and scrutinizing their inconsistencies. In doing so, the author skillfully navigates the labyrinth of theories and counter-arguments, presenting readers with a balanced and objective analysis.

Moreover, Williams successfully captures the complexities of the Prince Madog story, elucidating its significance within the wider context of early transatlantic exploration. By exploring factors such as Welsh settlement patterns, similarities between Welsh and Native American languages, and historical records of pre-Columbian contact, the author constructs a typically overlooked narrative that offers an alternative perspective on America's discovery.

Additionally, Williams's seamless and engaging writing style makes this book accessible to both scholars and general readers. His careful attention to detail and ability to explain complex concepts make for an absorbing and enlightening reading experience. The inclusion of maps and illustrations further aids in visualizing the theories and evidence discussed, enriching our understanding of Prince Madog's potential expedition.

However, one criticism of the book lies in its occasional repetitiveness. At times, certain points are reiterated, making certain sections seem overextended. While this repetitiveness may be viewed as a deliberate attempt to reinforce key arguments, it may also detract from the overall flow and readability of the narrative.

In conclusion, "An Enquiry into the Truth of the Tradition, Concerning the Discovery of America, by Prince Madog ab Owen Gwynedd, about the Year 1170" is a thought-provoking and meticulously researched work that challenges long-held historical narratives. John Williams's scholarly approach and engaging writing style make for an enlightening exploration of the Prince Madog tradition, breathing new life into a captivating but often overlooked aspect of early American history.

First Page:

We find allusions to it in the Writings of Ancient British Bards, who were dead before Columbus sailed on his first Western Voyage. We are told, also, by credible Authors, that some plain traces of Christianity, such as it was in the Days of Madog, were found in America, when the Spaniards landed there. No Nation, in Europe, hath ever pretended to have visited America before Behaim, Columbus, or Americus Vespucius, but the Welsh: it is therefore almost, if not quite certain, that if its religious Notions and Customs were derived from Europe, it must have been from the Ancient Britons... Continue reading book >>