Criticism on "The origin of species" By: Thomas Henry Huxley (1825-1895)
In "The Origin of Species", Thomas Henry Huxley presents a perceptive and comprehensive examination of Charles Darwin's groundbreaking work on evolution. Huxley is not only a prominent advocate for Darwin's theory, but also an influential biologist and naturalist in his own right, making his assessment highly relevant and valuable. Huxley's savvy critique navigates through the complexities of Darwin's theory, dissecting its various components and offering insightful analyses. He commends Darwin's meticulous observations and experimental approach, ultimately casting "The Origin of Species" as a revolutionary text that challenges long-standing theological and scientific beliefs. Huxley's enthusiasm for the subject matter is evident through his thorough and passionate exploration of Darwin's ideas, providing readers with a deep understanding of their implications for the natural world. One of the strengths of Huxley's criticism lies in his ability to address potential counterarguments and skepticism. He rigorously counters opposing views, presenting logical and evidence-based rebuttals that further bolster Darwin's evolutionary theory. By doing so, Huxley demonstrates his intellectual rigor and superior knowledge in the field, solidifying his credibility and reinforcing the validity of Darwin's ideas. Moreover, Huxley's writing style is engaging and accessible, making complex scientific concepts comprehensible to non-expert readers. He achieves this by using clear and concise language, employing vivid examples and analogies to elucidate intricate concepts. This approach ensures that the book is accessible to a wide range of audiences, contributing to its broader impact in the scientific community and beyond. However, one minor criticism of Huxley's work is his occasional use of technical jargon, which may dampen the overall accessibility of the text. While it is inevitable that some scientific terminology is required in discussing evolutionary concepts, Huxley could have provided more accessible explanations or footnotes to aid readers unfamiliar with these terms. Overall, Huxley's criticism of "The Origin of Species" provides a compelling and authoritative exploration of Darwin's monumental work. By presenting a balanced assessment and addressing potential objections, Huxley underscores the importance and validity of evolutionary theory. His ability to articulate complex concepts in a readable manner contributes to the wide influence of "The Origin of Species" and solidifies Huxley's reputation as a leading figure in the field. First Page: CRITICISMS ON "THE ORIGIN OF SPECIES" 'The Natural History Review', 1864 [1] By Thomas H. Huxley In the course of the present year several foreign commentaries upon Mr. Darwin's great work have made their appearance. Those who have perused that remarkable chapter of the 'Antiquity of Man,' in which Sir Charles Lyell draws a parallel between the development of species and that of languages, will be glad to hear that one of the most eminent philologers of Germany, Professor Schleicher, has, independently, published a most instructive and philosophical pamphlet (an excellent notice of which is to be found in the 'Reader', for February 27th of this year) supporting similar views with all the weight of his special knowledge and established authority as a linguist. Professor Haeckel, to whom Schleicher addresses himself, previously took occasion, in his splendid monograph on the 'Radiolaria' [2], to express his high appreciation of, and general concordance with, Mr. Darwin's views. But the most elaborate criticisms of the 'Origin of Species' which have appeared are two works of very widely different merit, the one by Professor Kolliker, the well known anatomist and histologist of Wurzburg; the other by M. Flourens, Perpetual Secretary of the French Academy of Sciences. Professor Kolliker's critical essay 'Upon the Darwinian Theory' is, like all that proceeds from the pen of that thoughtful and accomplished writer, worthy of the most careful consideration... Continue reading book >>

Criticism on "The origin of species" By: Thomas Henry Huxley (1825-1895)

In "The Origin of Species", Thomas Henry Huxley presents a perceptive and comprehensive examination of Charles Darwin's groundbreaking work on evolution. Huxley is not only a prominent advocate for Darwin's theory, but also an influential biologist and naturalist in his own right, making his assessment highly relevant and valuable.

Huxley's savvy critique navigates through the complexities of Darwin's theory, dissecting its various components and offering insightful analyses. He commends Darwin's meticulous observations and experimental approach, ultimately casting "The Origin of Species" as a revolutionary text that challenges long-standing theological and scientific beliefs. Huxley's enthusiasm for the subject matter is evident through his thorough and passionate exploration of Darwin's ideas, providing readers with a deep understanding of their implications for the natural world.

One of the strengths of Huxley's criticism lies in his ability to address potential counterarguments and skepticism. He rigorously counters opposing views, presenting logical and evidence-based rebuttals that further bolster Darwin's evolutionary theory. By doing so, Huxley demonstrates his intellectual rigor and superior knowledge in the field, solidifying his credibility and reinforcing the validity of Darwin's ideas.

Moreover, Huxley's writing style is engaging and accessible, making complex scientific concepts comprehensible to non-expert readers. He achieves this by using clear and concise language, employing vivid examples and analogies to elucidate intricate concepts. This approach ensures that the book is accessible to a wide range of audiences, contributing to its broader impact in the scientific community and beyond.

However, one minor criticism of Huxley's work is his occasional use of technical jargon, which may dampen the overall accessibility of the text. While it is inevitable that some scientific terminology is required in discussing evolutionary concepts, Huxley could have provided more accessible explanations or footnotes to aid readers unfamiliar with these terms.

Overall, Huxley's criticism of "The Origin of Species" provides a compelling and authoritative exploration of Darwin's monumental work. By presenting a balanced assessment and addressing potential objections, Huxley underscores the importance and validity of evolutionary theory. His ability to articulate complex concepts in a readable manner contributes to the wide influence of "The Origin of Species" and solidifies Huxley's reputation as a leading figure in the field.

First Page:

CRITICISMS ON "THE ORIGIN OF SPECIES"

'The Natural History Review', 1864

[1]

By Thomas H. Huxley

In the course of the present year several foreign commentaries upon Mr. Darwin's great work have made their appearance. Those who have perused that remarkable chapter of the 'Antiquity of Man,' in which Sir Charles Lyell draws a parallel between the development of species and that of languages, will be glad to hear that one of the most eminent philologers of Germany, Professor Schleicher, has, independently, published a most instructive and philosophical pamphlet (an excellent notice of which is to be found in the 'Reader', for February 27th of this year) supporting similar views with all the weight of his special knowledge and established authority as a linguist. Professor Haeckel, to whom Schleicher addresses himself, previously took occasion, in his splendid monograph on the 'Radiolaria' [2], to express his high appreciation of, and general concordance with, Mr. Darwin's views.

But the most elaborate criticisms of the 'Origin of Species' which have appeared are two works of very widely different merit, the one by Professor Kolliker, the well known anatomist and histologist of Wurzburg; the other by M. Flourens, Perpetual Secretary of the French Academy of Sciences.

Professor Kolliker's critical essay 'Upon the Darwinian Theory' is, like all that proceeds from the pen of that thoughtful and accomplished writer, worthy of the most careful consideration... Continue reading book >>

This book is in genre
Science

eBook links
Wikipedia – Thomas Henry Huxley
Wikipedia – Criticism on "The origin of species"

eBook Downloads
ePUB eBook • iBooks for iPhone and iPad • Nook • Sony Reader	Kindle eBook • Mobi file format for Kindle
Read eBook • Load eBook in browser	Text File eBook • Computers • Windows • Mac