Irish History and the Irish Question   By: Goldwin Smith (1823-1910)

In "Irish History and the Irish Question" by Goldwin Smith, the author delves deep into the complex and tumultuous history of Ireland. Through meticulous research and a comprehensive analysis, Smith presents readers with a thought-provoking exploration of the Irish nation's struggles, providing a valuable perspective on the historical context that shaped Ireland as we know it today.

One of the book's main strengths lies in Smith's ability to present a balanced account of Irish history, avoiding any overt biases or favoritism. He critically examines various aspects, including Irish nationalism, British rule, and the influence of religion, while duly acknowledging the role played by both sides. This objectivity allows readers to form their own opinions and gain a more nuanced understanding of the Irish question.

Smith's prose is eloquent and accessible, making "Irish History and the Irish Question" an engaging read for both scholarly and general audiences. He successfully combines historical facts with personal anecdotes and anecdotes, adding a human element that helps to bring the narrative to life. This storytelling approach creates a more relatable reading experience, allowing readers to immerse themselves in the events and emotions of the Irish people throughout history.

Moreover, the book offers a comprehensive overview of the various social, political, and economic factors that contributed to Ireland's troubles. Smith's meticulous research is evident in the wealth of information provided, ensuring readers are well-informed and presented with a multifaceted understanding of the Irish question. From the Great Famine to the challenges of achieving independence, the author presents an intricate tapestry of events, motivations, and outcomes, leaving no stone unturned.

However, one area where the book could be improved is in its brevity. At times, Smith's detailed approach may overwhelm readers unfamiliar with Irish history, potentially deterring them from fully engaging with the material. Condensing certain sections or introducing chapter summaries could enhance accessibility and make the book more approachable to a broader readership.

Overall, "Irish History and the Irish Question" is an insightful and comprehensive account of Ireland's tumultuous past. Smith's meticulous research and balanced perspective offer readers a valuable exploration of the Irish question, from both Irish and British perspectives. Though it may be a dense read in parts, the book is a must-read for those seeking a deeper understanding of Ireland's complex history, firmly establishing itself as a valuable addition to the canon of historical literature.

First Page:

A long summer was spent by me in that loveliest of all parks, the Phoenix, as the guest of Edward Cardwell, then Chief Secretary and real head of the Irish government. Under Cardwell's roof the Irish Question was fully discussed by able men, Robert Lowe among the number. But I had a still greater advantage in constant and lasting intercourse with such friends as Lord Chancellor O'Hagan, Sir Alexander Macdonald, the head of the Education Department, and other leading Irish Liberals of the moderate school, ardent patriots and thoroughgoing reformers though opposed to violence and disruption. To the teachings of these men in dealing with the Irish Question, I have always looked back for my best guidance. I did what I could generally to acquaint myself with the country and its people. I had the opportunity of seeing something of Maynooth as the guest of its excellent principal in that day. At that time there was rather a lull in the agrarian war, but religious antagonism was still marked. The fruit of my studies was a little book entitled "Irish History and Irish Character," in which I tried to show that the sources of Ireland's sorrows were to be found in natural circumstance and historical accident as much as in the crimes or follies of man in recent times... Continue reading book >>