Old Scores and New Readings Discussions on Music & Certain Musicians   By: John F. Runciman (1866-1916)

Old Scores and New Readings: Discussions on Music & Certain Musicians by John F. Runciman offers a captivating exploration of the world of music and its influential figures. This collection of essays examines various aspects of music, providing insightful commentary on the works of established musicians and shedding light on their artistic endeavors.

Throughout the book, Runciman employs a scholarly yet accessible writing style, making it suitable for both music enthusiasts and academic readers. His deep knowledge and passion for music are evident in every chapter, allowing readers to embark on an intellectual journey that spans different eras and genres.

One of the book's strengths lies in Runciman's ability to dissect musical compositions with precision and detail. His keen observations and nuanced analyses bring to life the essence of each piece, offering readers a deeper understanding and appreciation of the music itself. From classical symphonies to modern experimental compositions, Runciman provides a comprehensive exploration of diverse musical styles, showcasing his wide-ranging expertise and discerning taste.

Another notable aspect of this book is Runciman's focus on prominent musicians and their contributions. By delving into their personal lives and artistic choices, he reveals the motivations and influences that shaped their music. Through anecdotes and historical context, Runciman contextualizes the work of these musicians, illuminating their impact on the broader musical landscape.

Moreover, the book's structure allows readers to engage with each chapter independently, which is beneficial for those who want to delve into specific periods or artists. Whether one is interested in Beethoven's symphonies or Schoenberg's atonal compositions, Runciman's in-depth analysis provides thought-provoking insights and encourages further exploration.

While the book is filled with knowledge and passion, it sometimes lacks a cohesive narrative thread that connects the various chapters. However, this minor drawback is offset by the wealth of information and the engaging writing style that keeps readers thoroughly engaged throughout.

In summary, Old Scores and New Readings: Discussions on Music & Certain Musicians by John F. Runciman is a delightful read for both music enthusiasts and scholars alike. Runciman's expertise shines through his meticulous analyses, shedding light on the intricacies of musical works and the lives of influential musicians. This book serves as an invaluable resource for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of the rich tapestry of music and its creators.

First Page:

Many years ago, in the essay which is set second in this collection, I wrote (speaking of the early English composers) that "at length the first great wave of music culminated in the works of Tallis and Byrde ... Byrde is infinitely greater than Tallis, and seems worthy indeed to stand beside Palestrina." Generally one modifies one's opinions as one grows older; very often it is necessary to reverse them. This one on Byrde I adhere to: indeed I am nearly proud of having uttered it so long ago. I had then never heard the Mass in D minor... Continue reading book >>