On the Vice of Novel Reading. Being a brief in appeal, pointing out errors of the lower tribunal.   By: Young Ewing Allison (1853-1932)

On the Vice of Novel Reading is a captivating and thought-provoking book by Young Ewing Allison that dives deep into the world of novel reading. The author presents a compelling case against this popular form of literature, shedding light on the potential dangers and negative impacts it has on society.

Right from the start, Allison's argument is engaging and persuasive. He skillfully explores the various aspects of novel reading, ranging from its addictive nature to its potential to corrupt morals. By structuring his book as an appeal, Allison captivates readers from the very beginning, compelling them to reconsider their own reading habits.

One of the strengths of this book is Allison's ability to identify and highlight the errors of the lower tribunal, challenging commonly accepted beliefs about the value of novels. He presents a carefully constructed analysis of the detrimental effects of excessive novel reading, supported by strong evidence and insightful observations. This approach allows readers to critically assess their own reading habits and question the societal norms surrounding this form of entertainment.

Throughout the book, Allison's writing style is articulate and well-researched. He seamlessly weaves together historical references, anecdotes, and logical arguments to deliver a persuasive and powerful message. The author's passion for the topic shines through, adding a sense of urgency to his appeal and enhancing the overall impact of his words.

Despite the strength of Allison's arguments, some readers may find themselves disagreeing with his conclusions. The book may benefit from a more balanced perspective, considering the positive aspects of novel reading and acknowledging that not all individuals are affected in the same way. Additionally, the author occasionally makes broad generalizations that could be further substantiated to strengthen his case.

On the Vice of Novel Reading is an important contribution to the ongoing debate about the merits and drawbacks of this popular literary form. Young Ewing Allison's passionate appeal encourages readers to reassess their reading choices and contemplate the potential consequences of indulging too heavily in novels. Although some readers may find themselves challenging his arguments, this book remains a captivating and thought-provoking read that will undoubtedly inspire further discussion.

First Page:

Ever since the Novel reached the stage of development where it was demonstrated to be the most ingenious vehicle yet designed for conveying the protean thought and fancy of man, there has stood in the judgment book of Public Opinion the decree that novel reading was a vice. Of course, that judgment did not apply exclusively to the reading of novels. It was a sort of supplementary decree in which the name of this new invention was specifically added to the list of moral beguilements against which that judgment had anciently stood. Poetry, the Drama, even the virtuous History, had had their noses disjointed by this tribunal. But their great age and the familiarity of their presence had softened the decree in its enforcement... Continue reading book >>